Weekly Report for Week Ending August 16, 2001


 Exec. Comm. Agenda
Highlights
LSC
Administration
Hanford Observatory
Livingston Observatory
MIT
Caltech
Detector
40 Meter
TNI
LASTI
Data Analysis
LIGO II/Adv. R&D
Past Weekly Reports

The LIGO Executive Committee Agenda for Monday  August 20, 2001 will be:

 (Meeting time: 10:30 am Pacific Time)

Open meeting 10:30 - 11:30

  1. Announcements
  2. LSC Issues (Weiss)
  3. Comments on Weekly Report
  4. WBS 1 LIGO I Construction (Lindquist)
  5. WBS 2 LIGO Lab Operations
  6. WBS 3 and 4  Advanced R&D and LIGO II (Sanders)
Executive Committee only 11:30 - noon   Topics:
 

Special Items:  MINORITY UNDERGRAD OUTREACH, LSC MEETING REPRISE


Special Announcements:


Weekly Report Highlights
 


LSC Issues (Weiss)


no report


LIGO I Construction/LIGO Laboratory Administration (Lindquist)



 

WBS 1.2 LIGO Operations--Administration



LIGO Weekly Site Telecon (Lindquist)
 
  • There was no site teleconference on Thursday, August 16, 2001.

  • The list of current actions revised to reflect the status of open actions assigned through August 2, 2001 may be found at ACTION LIST.


    PROPERTY MANAGEMENT (Chargois)

    From: Ed Chargois <chargois_e@ligo.caltech.edu>


    DOCUMENT CONTROL CENTER (Turner, Mak)

    >From: Linda Turner - turner@ligo.caltech.edu>

    Web pages for the DCC give simple how-to's for document numbering, easy access to the latest on-line documents, and search capabilities for the DCC database. Take a look. . .

    ACCOMPLISHMENTS

    >From: Cleveland Mak <mak_c@ligo.caltech.edu>

    ACTIVITY

    Packages Faxes
    In 44 30
    Out 9 31

    Press here to access the DOCUMENT CONTROL CENTER WEB PAGE.


    COST SCHEDULE CONTROL SYSTEMS (Cunningham, Brambila, Kaufman)

    From: Esther Cunningham <esther@ligo.caltech.edu>

    Press here for ACCOUNTS PAYABLE HISTORY DATA.

    From: "Brambila, Ruth" <Ruth.Brambila@caltech.edu>

    From: Florence Kaufman <fkaufman@ligo.caltech.edu>

    SUBCONTRACTS MANAGEMENT (Petrac, Jasnow)

    From: irena@ligo.caltech.edu (Irena Petrac)

    From: Ed Jasnow <jasnow@ligo.caltech.edu>

    SUPPORT (Wood)

     
    Irene Baldon
    • Processed the paper work for nine (9) new trips (including Advance Checks written and hotel/car rental authorizations filled out and FAXed to appropriate vendors in various locations).  I have ten (10) trips in various stages of completion before ticketing can be done.  Worked on several trips that were changed or modified and assisted several more travelers with questions regarding their existing or potential travel.
    • Jim Covington returned nine (9) expense reports this week and has seventeen (17) he is working on.  I worked on one (1) that had extensive problems, one (1) relocation/visitor covering six-months of receipts and clarified a few more that Travel Audit or the traveler were having trouble with.  I completed twenty-eight (28) reports and there are thirty (30) reports to be done.  I'm holding one (1) report that needs a check and one (1) that needs a Transaction Report from the traveler before submitting.
    • Reconciled thirty-six (36) of a total of 128 items on my P-Card which required telephone calls to vendors who do not enter the traveler's name on their charges.  Assisted a few travelers with their reconciling and/or data entry.
    • Worked on the preparation and distribution of the Travel/Vacation Itinerary for August 13, 2001.  Performed normal recording and filing associated with Travel and Reimbursement.  Also performed miscellaneous duties as requested by various members of  the LIGO Project here at Caltech as well as from members of the staffs of each of the two (2) sites.  I continue to do MIT's travel to the sites for installation activities and also to assist them wherever possible.
    Dorothy Lloyd
    • Processed the usual requisitions, invoices and receiving on-line. For more detail, see "Cost Schedule Control Systems" report by Esther Cunningham.
    • Tracked and followed up on invoice problems.
    • Reviewed and recorded payments processed by Esther the week of August 6.
    • Continue to monitor contract and blanket order encumbrance and notify task managers when supplements are needed.
    • Began updating PO Log books for the period June through July (115 entries).
    • Jim continues with data entry in the LIGO database and supports Irene (travel) in the mornings and Linda and Cleveland (DCC) in the afternoons.
    Rita Torres
    • Placed several Pcard orders, and reconciled several after chasing down the invoices.  By end of today, will have reconciled 25 this period.  Picked up packages for people not here this week.
    • Spent some time trying to clarify a quote discrepancy with Penguin Computing for an LDAS order, which is now on hold.  The 16-week lead time item finally arrived, but continue to follow up on other long-lead orders.
    • Helping to assemble material for upcoming design review.  Did site trip updates.
    Elizabeth K. Wood

    Advanced LIGO (Frey)

    From: Thomas Frey <tfrey@ligo.caltech.edu>

    Progress Period from 08.10 to 08.16

    Accomplishments:

    Schedule 08.17 to 08.23:

    WBS 1.4.1.2   Project Controls (LIGO Construction)



    Reports (Lindquist)

    Gary and I met with the NSF on Wednesday, August 8, 2001.



    Change Control/Contingency (Lindquist)

    The following Change Requests have been submitted.  CR-010007 is new, submitted this week by Stan Whitcomb for reploishing and recoating the beamsplitter optic.
     

    CR-010006 WBS 1.1.4 (OPS) Roof Shelter for Concrete Pad Adjacent to Erosion Control Pond (Livingston) M. Coles
    CR-010007 WBS 1.2.4 Core Optics Components, Repolish/Recoat Beamsplitter S. Whitcomb

    Press for the latest Contingency Needs Projection.


    COST SCHEDULE CONTROL SYSTEMS (Duncan, Akutagawa)

    From: Kris Duncan <kris@ligo.caltech.edu>

    From: Cindy Akutagawa <cindy@ligo.caltech.edu>

    SUBCONTRACTS MANAGEMENT (Jasnow)

    From: Ed Jasnow <jasnow@ligo.caltech.edu>


    Quality/Safety (Tyler)

    >From: Bill Tyler <tyler@ligo.caltech.edu>

    No report this week.
     


    LIGO Hanford Observatory (LHO) Operations (Raab)


    no report


    LIGO Livingston Observatory (LLO) Operations (Coles)


    The cryo pumps at the vertex were regenerated this week and the RGA's are being prepped in anticipation of opening the gate valves down the arms for a quick "peek" while Stan is at LLO next week.

    We have gotten a price from LSU for the router for our second T1 line. They should be out here next Tuesday to install a temporary router, which they will loan us until ours arrives.

    Most of the SURF students have completed their summer projects and gave their final presentations to the LLO staff during the last week. Many of the staff are away this week on vacation, at the LSC meeting, or at professional training classes. A fuller report will be sent next week.


    Detector/Technical Support (Whitcomb, Coyne)


     
    Installation& Commissioning:
    Hanford
    Livingston
    Other Science/EngineeringActivities:
    Design/Analysis/Fab
    Issues/Concerns
    See also the Installation web page

    1.1 LHO INSTALLATION & COMMISSIONING

    2km Commissioning

    Matt Evans, Nergis Mavalvala, Stan Whitcomb
    Modified the gains in the QPD heads for the 2 km interferometyer to reduce the total range available, but to give more uniform coverage of the region that we do use.  Then used these new gains to set QPDY so that it was not saturating during the largest build-ups.

    The master (Matt) remeasured the gain coefficients and normalizations for the lock acquisition code, and this seemed to give good performance: lock acuisition in about one minute typically, lock durations of ~ one hour, recycling build-up typically in the 15-20 range.  We didn't see any of the periods of poor locking (as observed during E5), but we didn't have as much time trying to lock as we had during E5 either.  Matt used the full interferometer (State 4) to remeasure the gain coefficients for the lock acquisition code; this is supposed to give the same values as the ones measured in states 2 and 3, and amazingly enough, it did!

    4km Commissioning

    Luca Matone, Betsy Weaver, Corey Gray, Nergis Mavalvala, Stan Whitcomb
    Presently, we have 1W of incident power going to the 4k MC, the lock to the laser is robust and stable with a unity gain frequency of 50 kHz at most. We want to push the MC bandwidth to higher frequencies (~100kHz), and breathing of the error/control signals was observed around 10kHz.

    The MC high frequency actuator is the VCO in the PSL system, so we began to carefully address the PSL system since it is tied to the MC system. A few things were noticed:
      i.  the PSL bandwidth was limited to ~300kHz instead of the designed 1 MHz;
      ii. the PSL error/control system was also breathing around 10kHz.

    Measurements of the PSL electronics (alone) showed that the PC path was eating phase by 40 deg at 100kHz. An improvement in bandwidth for both PSL and MC systems could be achieved if this delay is decreased.

    Furthermore, the breathing observed in the error/control signals for both the MC and PSL systems, also showed up in the 1/(1+OL) PSL measurements. If the 1/(1+OL) measurement is non-stationary, then the gain of the system is non-stationary. The symptoms seem to indicate that the crossover between the FAST and PC path changes over time, causing, at times, the system to go instable. When the control is instable, that's when you observe the rising broad peak in the error/control signals in the MC/PSL systems. Since in the 1/(1+OL) measurementthe UGF never changes despite this non-stationary behavior, then something non-stationary is happening in the FAST path of the PSL.

    Once the PSL/MC situation was assesed, we proceeded in aligning the transmitted MC beam to the 4k PRM. At the moment, we have found the reflected beam off of RM, the reflected beam off of ITMX and ITMY, and we began observing Michelson fringes.
     

    Suspension Tuning

    Mark Barton
    This week I was at the LSC meeting and did some training with the LHO control room operators on doing ring-down tests of the pendulum modes.

    1.2LLO INSTALLATION & COMMISSIONING

    New MC Servo

    Peter King, Rich Abbott, Rana Adhikari
    Completed installation of the LLO modecleaner servo

    PSL

    Peter King
    During installation of the new modecleaner servo a problem was noticed with the XY212 module.  The input resistors for the XY212 were swapped out to allow operation with 5V inputs.  As I recall, after this was done everything seemed okay but I could be wrong.  The new MEDM screens were moved from the testing area to the release area.
     

    2.0 OtherEngineering and Scientific Activities

    2.1 Design/Analysis/Fab

    Core Optics

    GariLynn Billingsley
    Bob Oreb of CSIRO visited Wednesday.  We discussed the beamsplitter specification for the two  beamsplitters currently at CSIRO for repolish (one for first polish.)  I suggested the possibility of changing the required sag of the parts to account for the roughly known change in sag due to coating stress and non-uniformity.  If we assume that these two pieces will be re-coated at REO we can have them pre-shaped at CSIRO so that they will be closer to flat once they are coated.

    Optical modeling

    Bill Kells
    Back now at CIT, I have been working on FFT simulations of matching under various conditions, to better understand the Arm coupling efficiency for LIGO-II.

    Suspension Design

    Janeen Romie
    Working on BS and test mass suspension and fixture designs for 40m IFO

    IOO PERISCOPE

    Mike Smith, Ken Mailand
    The prototype (1st article) periscope body has been welded and the feet pads have been lapped to a common flat surface. The structure will be at CIT on 8/16 for the mounting plate holes to be drilled. The mirror mounting plate and accessory bracketry are being fabricated, and are expected to be available for testing at CIT the week of Aug 20. A vibration analysis will be performed with the periscope/top mirror mounted on a Newport optics table in the OTC lab in W. Bridge.

    PSL

    Peter King
    Another trickle of super-polished substrates from Mindrum Precision has arrived, leaving 8 on back order.  Of the 40 substrates inspected to date, identifying the super-polished side of 13 of them is near impossible because of the lack of distinguishing marks.

    40 m PSL: The optical spectrum analyzer arrived, along with the 29 MHz Pockels cell used for locking the modecleaner.

    Lee Cardenas

    Rick Karwoski
    PSL Custom Boards: GEO and Site Spares: We are working to cover the GEO and spares requirements for sites. Additionally we are in the process of putting together a full set of spares for Livingston/LASTI/40m

    Intensity Stabilization

    Sander Liu
    Completed checking couple of 80 MHz VCOs. Both units are for future delivery. Finished testing couple to FSS servo boards. Both units are ready for delivery. In the process of repairing one PMC servo board that were damaged in the 40M by accident.

    LSC

    Rich Abbot, Mohana Mageswaran, Flavio Nocera

    CDS/DAQ/ASC/LSC/Digital Suspensions

    Rolf Bork
    Working on preparations for LHO visit next week.  List of work for next week and status:
    1) Install/test latest digital suspension (DSC) code, which provides support for GDS excitation/test points: 2) Install/test 4k ASC system: 3) Upgrade 2k LSC processor to 1GHz pentium:
    Part shipped.  Will test and tune code next week.

    4) Assemble the 4k suspension data collection unit.
    Since a whitening board to interface between coil driver monitors and DAQS was never specified, we would need to assemble a fair number of generic DAQ interface modules to connect the coil signals.  I have to check on how many we have available.

    5) Run mid station DAQS with GDS arbitary waveform generator code to drive ICS115 DAC outputs:
    Having some difficulties getting this to run in our test setup.  Appears though all communications to DAC are correct, but get no output voltages.  Lori will continue to work on solving the problems with this.
     


    40 Meter Interferometer (Weinstein)




    Thermal Noise Interferometer (Libbrecht)


    This week we encountered our first setback in noise reduction. After much
    initial success reducing laser frequency noise by increasing the gain of
    the mode cleaner, we implemented additional gain boosts at low frequencies
    and saw the noise increase.  We are currently working on resolving this
    problem.  Many thanks to Rick Karwoski and Sander Liu at CDS for loaning us
    a VCO!


    LASTI (Zucker)


    LASTI (Harry, Mason, Mason, MacInnis, Miller, Mittleman, Ottaway,
    Rollins, Shoemaker, Zucker):
     

    This week we concentrated on preparing for the LASTI review at the
    LSC meeting.  The baseline optical layout, interferometer parameter
    choices and associated noise budget, PSL and
    infrastructure progress, and near-term test plan options were among the
    highlighted items.  Ken also showed a conceptual design for fitting
    hydraulic seismic pre-isolators under the HAM13 stack. Overall
    the review was very productive, and the committee provided useful guidance
    through questions and comments. Presentation graphics will shortly
    be available under LIGO-G010269-00; Peter Saulson, committee chair, will
    assemble and submit a formal report in a week or so.
     

    Meanwhile in the lab Myron and Fred continued preparing lab infrastructure
    and parts for cleaning, bakeout, assembly and balancing
    of SOS suspensions for the short
    cavity test. We've tentatively arranged a visit from Betsy Weaver in
    mid-September (after her honeymoon!) to train us in the SOS preparation
    and balancing process.


    Data Analysis and Computing (Lazzarini)


    _______________
     

    E2E MODELLING:
    _______________
     

    Mode Mismatch
    -------------
    (Biplab)
     (i) Checked that the effects of mode-mismatch simulated in full LIGO model
         including recycling summation cavity match well with analytical derivation.
     (ii) MIT's FFT: With help from Bill Kells sorted out several issues about FFT runs.
         Started running FFT code and comparing results with full LIGO e2e runs.
         Results of comparison at this initial stage are encouraging but I see need
         of more detailed understanding of how FFT code runs corresponding to a
         same-parameter run in e2e or vice versa in order to sort out differences.
     

    CVS Archive
    ------------
    (Ed Maros) Moved the CVS archive for the e2e work onto ldas-sw.
        Gave presentation on how to use the CVS archive in its new location.
     

    Alfi
    ----
    (Bruce) Continuing implementation of Alfi box and primitive file parser for Alfi5.
     

    (Melody)
    - Discussed Java coding conventions with Bruce. Currently modifying the
      existing code to comply with the conventions.
    - Reorganizing the Java code packages. The code should be checked back in by
      COB Thursday.
     

    Mechanical simulation work (from July upto last week)
    -----------------------------------------------------
    (Virginio) This is my report with just the main activities about the mechanical
     simulation. I apologize for including in a single weekly report the activity
     of the entire month of July (almost).
     

     - Three-dimensional LIGO I Suspension simulation is ready to be plugged into
     e2e. The simulation includes a realistic topology of the actuators and sensors
     also. Geometrical suspension asymmetries can be easily introduced. The cross
     check with an experimental spectrum using a set of OSEMs suspension has been
     successfully done with an agreement of about 2%. To obtain a better
     characterization of the suspension local controls, a set of new measurements
     needs to be done.
     

     - A simple way to introduce the Hytec models of the BSC stack is under study.
     At first look it seems necessary to introduce some new functionalities to MSE
     to allow the possibility to merge two separate state space representations.
     

     - Some tests have been done to introduce the suspension violin modes also.
     

    Boston week:  (Assembly/Installation)
     

     Worked mainly with Calum Torrie, Norna Robertson and Rich Mittleman to assemble
     the second quadruple pendulum chain. Thanks the work I made during the weekend
     I was able to run some measurements to characterize one chain of the suspension.
     I worked essentially on the reacting chain because we didn't have any OSEM really
     aligned yet.
     

     - Mounted three LVDTs which allowed to measure the longitudinal transfer
     functions from the "new" mass to the "upper" mass and to the "middle" mass,
     using the upper most stage as mechanical compliance. The sensor parts were
     attached to the suspension masses by using a pretty good double sided scotch tape.
     

     - Mounted also another coil actuator (an old and bigger OSEM) between the two
     upper masses acting against the reacting chain but I was not able to make it
     work using the control box inputs (pin out incompatibilities).
     

    Measurements:
     

     I took several sensors spectral densities hoping to be able to make some
     frequency mode characterization. I did not have time to do a more accurate
     system identification.
     

     I measure the t.f. which seems to be reasonably good.
     Those measurements are affected by a large cross coupling with all the DOF
     because the chain was not properly aligned yet and because of the
     orientation of the sensors and the actuators. The actuation was done using
     the control box longitudinal input.
     

    Observations:
     

     The LVDTs seem to work fine and particularly good for t.f. measurement
     (good sensitivity and large dynamic range)
     

     It is clear that it is not easy to measure the t.f. using the OSEMs
     because of the small dynamic range of the sensor and because of the small
     clearance between the magnets and the coils. All the coils need to be
     quite well aligned to be able to shake enough the mass. This alignment
     doesn't seem to be critical for the damping of the suspension.
     

     I didn't have time to measure any t.f useful for the study of the performance
     of the active damping. The LVDT can probably be used to verify the efficiency
     of the damping for the lower stages.
     

     The most important result is that the results obtained show the possibility
     to measure the transfer function of the entire chain (4 stages) using the
     LVDTs as sensors.
     

    Last week
     

     Worked with Giancarlo Cella to fix some library bugs. The following ones
     seem to be solved:
     

     - The phase lag going through the mechanical resonances is now properly
     computed when a viscous damping is plugged into the simulation.
     

     - The simulation bug on the violin modes of a wire under tension (without
     the flexural contribution) seems to be solved. The Library now works
     properly to compute the right frequency spectrum of a simple suspension made
     of a wire and a bob. This approximation works reasonably well (applicable)
     when the wire tension is high compared the flexural restoring force.
     Comparison with a real experimental data gives a good result less than 10%
     of discrepancy in the frequency spectrum. Next step which is under progress
     also is to check the violin mode simulation inside a more complex system.
     

     - Wrote a simple program to check the class which implements the flat Blade
     (a la Virgo) to finally have the description of all the main internal modes
     of the advance LIGO suspension.
     


    LIGO II/Advanced R&D (Sanders)


    From Mark Barton:
    I also did more reverse-engineering of the Glasgow Matlab model of the Advanced LIGO reference design

    From Rich Abbott
    Worked on the specifications and implementation for the next generation capacitance position sensors with the vendor

    Received the new voice coil actuators from LLO and have begun the process of characterization in order to best design or buy a driver.

    From: GariLynn Billingsley <Billingsley_G@ligo.caltech.edu>
    Bob Oreb of CSIRO visited Caltech on the 15th.  Bob reports that sub Angstrom measurements of the microroughness of polished sapphire have been obtained while experimenting with different polishing approaches.

    From: HELENA ARMENDULA
    Silicate bonding
    Recent tests on silica/sapphire bonds show that, when
    the bonded substrates are baked at 120 degrees C,
    there is a considerable amount of stress on the silica
    glass causing it to brake in most cases.
    We investigated bonds that were baked shortly after
    manufactured as well as 60 day old bonds with the same
    results.
    Strees is not observed on un-baked bonds.


    For additional information about this report, contact sanders@ligo.caltech.edu